What Are Australian Listed Property Trusts (A-REITs)?
Australian Real Estate Investment Trusts (A-REITs, formerly listed property trusts or LPTs) are ASX-listed vehicles that own income-producing commercial real estate - shopping centres, office towers, industrial estates, logistics hubs, data centres and healthcare facilities. The ASX 200 A-REIT index includes around 20 trusts with a combined market capitalisation exceeding $130 billion. Unlike direct property, A-REIT units can be bought or sold in seconds during market hours.
- Stapled securities: Most large A-REITs are stapled - a trust unit (holding property) is stapled to a company share (holding management operations). This is why Scentre Group, Goodman Group and GPT pay distributions that include both trust income and company dividends with different tax treatments.
- Distribution composition matters: A-REIT distributions typically include: (a) tax-deferred income - return of depreciation, reduces your cost base rather than being taxable now; (b) trust income - taxed at your marginal rate; (c) capital gains - may qualify for 50% CGT discount if held 12+ months; (d) franked dividends - if the stapled company component pays dividends. The tax statement (AMMA) issued after 30 June breaks this down.
- Tax-deferred distribution example: If you receive $1,000 in distributions and $400 is tax-deferred, only $600 is taxable income this year. The $400 reduces your cost base - so when you eventually sell, a larger capital gain is crystallised. This is a deferral, not an exemption.
- Index ETF options: VAP (Vanguard Australian Property Securities, 0.23% MER) and SLF (SPDR S&P/ASX 200 Listed Property, 0.40% MER) provide diversified A-REIT exposure. RINC (Betashares Australian Real Estate ETF, 0.38% MER) focuses on income.
Direct Property: What You Actually Own
Direct property means purchasing a physical asset - residential investment property (house, unit, townhouse) or commercial property (retail, office, industrial). You hold legal title, control the asset, and bear all responsibilities of ownership.
- Residential vs commercial: Residential yields are typically 2.5–4.5% gross in major capitals (lower in Sydney/Melbourne, higher in Brisbane/Perth/Adelaide as at 2025). Commercial yields are typically 4.5–8%+ gross but carry longer vacancy periods, tenant-fit-out costs and higher purchase prices. Commercial leases are generally triple-net - tenant pays outgoings.
- Negative gearing: If rental income is less than interest + expenses, the loss is deductible against other income (wages, business income). This reduces tax now but requires ongoing cash subsidy of the property. Positive gearing means rent exceeds expenses - taxable, but cash-flow positive.
- Land tax: Every state and territory levies land tax on investment properties above a threshold. NSW threshold is $1,075,000 (2024–25 general rate). Victoria threshold is $300,000 (significantly lower). Land tax does not apply to your primary residence in most states but applies to all investment properties - including through trusts and companies in most states.
- Depreciation and BMT schedules: The ATO allows deductions for capital works (Division 43, 2.5%/year for buildings constructed after 15 September 1987) and plant and equipment (Division 40, effective life of each item). A quantity surveyor's tax depreciation schedule typically costs $600–$900 and generates thousands in deductions over the asset's life. For properties purchased from 9 May 2017, second-hand plant and equipment can no longer be depreciated by the new investor (applies to previously used items in established properties).
Head-to-Head: The Seven Key Differences
These are the factors that typically determine which vehicle is right for a given investor.
- Transaction costs: Direct property: stamp duty (3–5.5% of purchase price in most states), conveyancing ($1,500–$3,000), building/pest inspection ($500–$700), selling agent commission (1.5–3%), legal costs. Total round-trip cost: typically 7–10% of property value. A-REITs: brokerage ($5–$20 per trade for most online brokers). Breakeven on direct property requires meaningful capital growth just to recover entry costs.
- Liquidity: A-REITs trade on ASX - you can sell $500,000 of Goodman Group units within 30 seconds on a normal trading day. Settlement is T+2. Direct property: 30–90 day settlement after finding a buyer. In a downturn, forced sellers face months of delay or large discounts. Liquidity premium is the single largest structural advantage of A-REITs.
- Leverage: Direct property: banks will lend 80% LVR (or 90% with LMI) on residential investment property - powerful in rising markets. A-REITs use internal gearing (typically 20–40% LVR at the trust level). Retail investors can margin lend against A-REITs but this adds a second layer of risk. Direct property offers higher accessible leverage for retail investors.
- Tax treatment of income: A-REIT distributions include tax-deferred components (no current-year tax, reduces cost base) - effectively deferring tax. Direct property income is fully assessable in the year received, offset by interest and expenses. A-REIT distributions in accumulation phase are taxed at your marginal rate (same as direct property rent) but the deferred component provides a cash-flow advantage.
- Management burden: A-REITs: zero management effort. Professional management teams handle leasing, maintenance, capital expenditure, tenant relations, development. Annual report and tax statement are your only obligations. Direct property: property manager (7–10% of rent), maintenance calls, vacancy periods, tenant disputes, insurance, council rates, water, strata if applicable. Time cost is real.
- Correlation and diversification: A-REITs trade on ASX and correlate with equities - during the March 2020 COVID crash, the A-REIT index fell ~40%, similar to equities, even as physical property prices held up. Direct property prices move more slowly and with lower correlation to sharemarket volatility. For true diversification against sharemarket risk, direct property does a better job - but requires far more capital.
- Control and improvement: Direct property investors can renovate, subdivide, develop, add a granny flat or rezone - each potentially adding value beyond market growth. A-REIT unitholders have no control over individual assets and cannot access leverage at the property level.
Which Suits Your Strategy?
Neither vehicle is universally superior. The right choice depends on your capital base, income, tax position, time horizon and risk tolerance.
- A-REITs suit you if: You have less than $100,000 to invest in property (direct is impossible at this scale), you want instant liquidity, you prefer no management involvement, you want diversification across hundreds of properties and property types, or you are investing inside super (where gearing via direct property requires an SMSF LRBA - complex and costly).
- Direct property suits you if: You want maximum accessible leverage (banks lend 80%+ vs property, not equity), you are in the 37–47% marginal tax bracket and can benefit from negative gearing to reduce tax now, you have a specific local market view or value-add strategy (renovation, development), or you want an asset that is emotionally tangible and less volatile in reported value.
- SMSF investors: An SMSF can purchase direct commercial property from a related party at market value (Business Real Property rules apply - must be used wholly and exclusively in a business). Residential cannot be purchased from or used by a related party. An LRBA (Limited Recourse Borrowing Arrangement) allows gearing inside the SMSF at the safe harbour rate of 8.85% for real property (2024–25). A-REITs inside super are simply held as listed securities - no structural complexity, fully liquid.
- Combined approach: Many Australian investors hold both. A-REITs inside super (where liquidity and simplicity matter) and a direct investment property outside super (where negative gearing offsets wage income and leverage amplifies returns). The two structures serve different functions in the same portfolio.
Roopon: More Money to Invest Each Week
Whether you're building toward a deposit on an investment property or growing an A-REIT portfolio inside your brokerage account, every dollar saved on everyday spending accelerates your timeline. Roopon members access exclusive partner discounts on groceries, fuel, dining, health services and more - and from $19.99/month, the savings typically pay for membership many times over.
Members receive FREE included prize-draw entries per their plan and published campaign terms. Extra packages exist for specific campaigns. See /giveaways for live prizes. Join at roopon.com.au and see current partner deals.
Ready to Start Winning?
Join Roopon today for exclusive member discounts plus FREE included prize-draw entries per your plan and published campaign terms. Extra packages exist for specific campaigns. See /giveaways for live prizes.
